From the President General’s Mailbox: 5th Continental Congress

Denise Doring VanBuren, President General

One of the best parts of serving as the 45th President General is receiving all sorts of interesting mail from members, organizations, scholarship recipients, award winners, etc. Several months ago, I was delighted to receive an intriguing envelope from Susan Watkins, who has been a member of the Gen. Israel Putnam Chapter of Massachusetts since 1963. While sorting through her late mother’s papers, which “had survived, unopened, for several moves,” Ms. Watkins came upon reports of the 5th Continental Congress, which had been conducted in the auditorium of a church in Washington, D.C., in February 1896. The 20 typed pages were presumably delivered as the report of chapter delegates at their March 5, 1896, meeting.

The pages were matched by our Historian General’s Office to the Official Proceedings published in the April 1896 DAR Magazine in order to confirm that they did, indeed, reflect the events of the National Society’s fifth annual congress. They were written by four women, whose National Numbers confirm them as early members. Unlike the formal proceedings, the women also recorded social events, notable attendees, decorations, clothing and other interesting highlights. While space does not allow me to include everything that they recorded, I thought that you might be interested in reading their insights via a few excerpted reflections from our annual meeting more than 125 years ago. (I have inserted occasional parenthetical references for clarity.)

“The Congress opened on Tuesday in the Church of Our Father, the auditorium of which had been divided into sections, the backs of the pews had the name of the delegation on printed cards and there were 47 states or territories represented.”

“The report of Mrs. Charles S. Johnson in charge of the organization of chapters detailed fully the work done during the past year. She has endeavored to start chapters in four states and territories not yet represented, Alaska, Arizona, Idaho and Nevada….The Society now has chapters in Halifax, Nova Scotia; Geneva, Switzerland; and but for the non-receipt of a letter, Mrs. Johnson said she could have reported a chapter in Hawaii.”

“The membership has now reached over 12,000 and those most active hope to see it at 100,000.” Mrs. Johnson continued, “I have had some correspondence with regard to a union with the Daughters of the Revolution, … I am sure, (you) will be pleased to know that I am reliably informed that there is a very special sentiment among the Daughters of the Revolution in favor of union.” (The Daughters of the Revolution, also founded in 1890, disbanded in 1986.)

“Mrs. Roberdeau Buchanan, Rec. Sec. General, had one of the most trying positions of any of the officers of the Congress and her patience is remarkable. She said the society had doubled in membership during the past year. In closing, Mrs. Buchanan gave a list of the banner states. Conn. leads in having 30 chapters and a membership of 1,649. New York, Pennsylvania, and Massachusetts follow … New York City has the greatest number of members in any city or town. … Mrs. Philip Hichborn, Registrar General, stated that 4,306 Applications had been received, of which 4,020 had been verified.” 

“On Wed. morning considerable time was spent in discussing whether male or female attorneys should be employed by the National Board, which was finally left to the judgment of the National Officers. It was a very amusing debate in which the ‘new woman’ figured conspicuously”

“The (Wednesday) afternoon session was must turbulent, the scene at times defied description… Under very trying circumstances, when every one was trying to speak at once, Mrs. Foster called upon Mrs. Miranda Tulloch to preside; she did very well but could not keep the delegates in check, and the more latitude given them the worse they were. Nearly the entire afternoon was spent in discussion of the society magazine…(it) has been a bone of contention for a long time and it was picked clean.”

“On Thursday, the election of officers was held. Mrs. Mary Lockwood as presiding officer had her hands full all day, and used the gavel nearly as vigorously as (U.S. House) Speaker (Thomas Bracket) Reed when the house is out of order. Mrs. Lockwood did adopt Czar rules. She would try to preserve order till the scene before her was chaos. Then she would call out ‘Ladies, there must be quiet. Take your seats. We will transact no more business until you do.’”

“One of the pet schemes of the National Board is the erection of a Continental Hall in Washington in which each state shall furnish a room and where tablets shall be erected to all Revolutionary Soldiers. Ten per cent of income of the Society is laid aside for this purpose… then followed a discussion as to the hall, the property yet to be purchased on which it will stand and the price, $250,000. Mrs. Wittenmeyer advised caution, saying it was easier to get in debt than out.”

“One day (DAR Member) Mrs. U.S. Grant entered the church and was escorted to the platform. The ladies received her with generous handclapping, remaining on their feet until Mrs. Grant had taken her seat at the right of the President General.”

“An interesting group of children assembled at the White House and were made welcome by Mrs. Cleveland. They were members of the National Society Children of the American Revolution, and the cordial handshake and kindly ‘good morning’ extended to them by the wife of the President was a greeting that will doubtless be remembered by the little ones for many years to come….they proceeded singly into the Blue Parlor, where Mrs. Cleveland stood alone and shook hands with each.” (At the time, 57 C.A.R. societies contained 700 members.)

Delegates attended a reception hosted by the Sons of the American Revolution to honor the birth of George Washington at the opulent Arlington Hotel. “Flags were gracefully draped over the doorways and suspended over the front of the massive mirrors were huge wreaths of greens with yards of wide satin ribbon arranged similar to a sunburst, with streamers reaching out and entwining the gilt frames. … (Three parlors) were filled all evening with beautiful women, representing the stately, languid beauty of the South, the dignified and stern of the North, and the restless, energetic women of the West. All were attired in full evening dress, lending brilliancy to the scene.”

In closing, I suspect that your own chapter contains these kinds of fascinating primary source documents within your archives. Given that each chapter should be sending representation to Continental Congress and that delegates should provide reports as a result, you can likely find reports that mirror these from different eras in our history. They provide a glimpse into the lives and perspectives of the women who laid the foundation of our National Society and your chapter – I hope that you will explore them to learn more about these early Daughters and the times in which they lived.

send-a-commentSend Us a comment